5 Things You Can Do If Your New Jersey House Appraises Low

There are few things discouraging when trying to sell your New Jersey House Fast than receiving a low appraisal. To help you overcome this possible obstacle, we have 5 things you can do if your New Jersey house appraises low.


The first step when your house appraises low is to ask for a copy of the appraisal and go through it with a fine-tooth comb.

Make sure you keep your agent involved in this process to leave no stone unturned; they’re certainly used to analyzing appraisals for mistakes and questionable details if your house should appraise low.

Another important piece of documentation to request is a list of comparable sales the appraiser used to help determine the value of your property. Your agent should have a list of the comparable sales they used to determine pricing your property when putting it on the market, and contrasting these two documents will help you and your agent understand how the appraiser ultimately came to their conclusions.


After going through the appraisal and measuring up the two different lists of comparable sales, you may find it best to take things up with your lender and do the appraisal all over again.

This will require asking your lender to appeal the appraisal themselves, and your lender will likely ask for some solid reasoning for the appeal. Legitimate reasons for appealing an appraisal include errors in the appraisal itself, improper data in the comparable sales, and the appraiser is unfamiliar with your city or neighborhood.

A lot of different, minute variables contribute to the end results of an appraisal, and sometimes people make mistakes.


If appealing the appraisal is not an option – or you aren’t comfortable attempting it in the first place – it’s worth a try to see if the buyer is willing to renegotiate in order to save the entire deal.

Keep in mind that the buyer will not want to pay more for your home than the amount at which it was appraised. This means it’s very likely that the buyer will request the agreed-to price for the home is dropped to a maximum of the appraised value.

Hitting the point that necessitates renegotiation is where you need to determine if you’re ok with getting less for your home versus rolling the dice all over again with another buyer and another appraisal.


As a home seller, you may end up in a situation where you feel it’s best to walk away from an offer or negotiation and try again from scratch.

An understandably difficult decision to make, canceling the sale, and relisting your home will eventually bring another buyer that could be the magic ingredient necessary to turn everything around. When you find yourself without the leverage to get what you want from the deal, be ready and willing to walk away and start over.


As you’re navigating the web of negotiations and appeals, the overarching thing you need to do is keep your calm and don’t let the stress affect your decision-making abilities.

Leaning on your agent through the fallout when your house appraises low is a good start to help share the load and get a clear perspective on the best course of action. Whichever route you determine to be best for you under the circumstances, you will need to approach everything going forward with a professional attitude.

Professional Backup When Your House Appraises Low

We Buy Houses In New Jersey and we know Appraisals are a necessary part of the home-selling process, but it can be frustrating and damaging when your house appraises low. Contact our New Jersey team for help at 908-448-2770 if you need to navigate this situation!

Get More Real Estate Market Info... Subscribe Below!

Learn more about us and find other resources on selling your house below. Like us, follow us, connect!